The Costello Agency

Built on Family. Guided by Integrity. Focused on You.

At The Costello Agency, we believe protecting families is more than a profession—it’s a responsibility. As an independent insurance agency located near Athens, Georgia, our mission is simple: help families protect what matters most through honest guidance, ethical practices, and solutions built around real life.

We are a team of dedicated insurance brokers who work for our clients—not insurance companies. That independence allows us to shop multiple top-rated carriers and recommend coverage that truly fits your needs, goals, and budget.

Our Roots, Our Values

The Costello Agency was built on strong Italian family values—loyalty, hard work, and an unwavering commitment to doing what’s right. In our family, your word means everything. Promises aren’t suggestions; they’re commitments.

Those values shape how we do business every day:

• We treat every client like family

• We believe trust is earned, not assumed

• We do the right thing—even when nobody is watching

Insurance is about showing up when it matters most. That’s not something we take lightly.

Integrity Over Sales

We don’t believe in pressure, shortcuts, or one-size-fits-all solutions. Our approach is rooted in integrity, transparency, and education—so you can make confident decisions about your coverage.

Our clients work with us because they know:

• Recommendations are based on need, not commission

• Coverage is explained clearly and honestly

• Their best interest always comes first

If a policy doesn’t make sense for you, we’ll tell you. That’s our promise.

Dedicated to Our Clients

Life changes—and your protection should evolve with it. We build long-term relationships, not one-time transactions. From your first policy to future reviews, we’re here to support you through every stage of life.

Whether it’s protecting your home, your income, your family, or your legacy, our team is committed to being a trusted partner you can rely on.

Our Promise to You

At The Costello Agency, we stand for:

• ✔️ Ethical business practices

• ✔️ Honest, client-first advice

• ✔️ Loyalty to the families we serve

• ✔️ Keeping our word—always

Because when it comes to protecting your family, nothing matters more than trust.

The Costello Agency
Independent Insurance Brokers